OUP user menu

A developmental and genetic classification for malformations of cortical development: update 2012

(CC)
A. James Barkovich, Renzo Guerrini, Ruben I. Kuzniecky, Graeme D. Jackson, William B. Dobyns
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/brain/aws019 1348-1369 First published online: 16 March 2012

Summary

Malformations of cerebral cortical development include a wide range of developmental disorders that are common causes of neurodevelopmental delay and epilepsy. In addition, study of these disorders contributes greatly to the understanding of normal brain development and its perturbations. The rapid recent evolution of molecular biology, genetics and imaging has resulted in an explosive increase in our knowledge of cerebral cortex development and in the number and types of malformations of cortical development that have been reported. These advances continue to modify our perception of these malformations. This review addresses recent changes in our perception of these disorders and proposes a modified classification based upon updates in our knowledge of cerebral cortical development.

  • cerebral cortex
  • malformation of cortical development
  • microcephaly
  • cortical dysplasia
  • polymicrogyria

Introduction

Malformations of cortical development have been of interest to clinicians and neuroscientists for many decades (Friede, 1989; Sarnat, 1992; Norman et al., 1995). In 1996, the term malformation of cortical development was introduced to designate a collectively common group of disorders in children with developmental delay and young people with epilepsy; a classification scheme was introduced, based upon the earliest developmental step at which the developmental process was disturbed (Barkovich et al., 1996). Updates of the classification relied more heavily on genetics, and noted that the classification likely would never be finalized because of ongoing discoveries (Barkovich et al., 2001, 2005). Since the last revision, many new syndromes have been described, and many new genes and mutations of known genes have been identified. A new classification has been proposed for focal cortical dysplasias (FCDs), and our knowledge of the molecular biology of both normal and abnormal cortical development has evolved.

This abundance of new information has largely fit well into the existing framework, but a few structural changes and the addition of new syndromes and genes were needed to remain consistent with current literature. Here we present an updated version of the classification. Many disorders listed in Appendix 1 and Supplementary Table 2 are not mentioned in the text because discussing all of them would make the article prohibitively long. The discussions, therefore, focus on those disorders that have conceptual importance whereas the tables attempt to include as many disorders as possible, recognizing that some will inevitably be missed. Hopefully, this update will prove useful for clinicians evaluating and treating affected patients, as well as for researchers investigating these important disorders.

Recent advances in embryology of cerebral cortical development

The cerebral cortex is a modular structure (Cholfin and Rubenstein, 2007; Cholfin and Rubenstein, 2008; Hoch et al., 2009): modules of neurons are induced in a neuroepithelial sheet and subsequently differentiate, migrate and organize into a functioning cerebral cortex. Neuronal induction results from a combination of graded extracellular signals and transcription factor gradients that operate across several fields of neocortical progenitor cells (Sansom and Livesey, 2009). This process is regulated by interplay between intrinsic genetic mechanisms and extrinsic information relayed to cortex by thalamocortical input and other, largely unknown, factors (O'Leary et al., 2007; Rakic et al., 2009; Supplementary material).

Although details of the neural cell proliferation differ among mammalian species, GABAergic cortical interneurons are produced in the medial and caudal ganglionic eminences, and the subventricular zone of the pallial (dorsal) germinal epithelium (Petanjek et al., 2009; Miyoshi et al., 2010; Lui et al., 2011) and migrate tangentially (from the medial ganglionic eminences) or radially (from the dorsal subventricular zone) to the developing cortex. The precise details in humans are not yet known (Lui et al., 2011). In the dorsal subventricular zone, neuroepithelial cells differentiate into radial glial cells, in part promoted by fibroblast growth factor (Sahara and O'Leary, 2009). Whereas neuroepithelial cells divide symmetrically to expand their numbers, radial glial cells divide asymmetrically to both self-renew and generate restricted intermediate progenitor cells, which divide symmetrically to produce two or more neurons but no progenitors. Both radial glial and intermediate progenitor cells produce glutamatergic neurons (Merkle and Alvarez-Buylla, 2006; Kang et al., 2009). Another class of precursor cells in the dorsal ventricular zone, the short neural precursors, appear to be committed to symmetrical neurogenic divisions (Howard et al., 2006; Stancik et al., 2010).

Based upon interspecies comparisons, the generation of increased numbers of intermediate progenitor cells underlies increased cortical complexity and size (Kriegstein et al., 2006). Thus, the balance between self-renewal and progression to a more restricted state is a critical factor in regulating the number of intermediate progenitor cells, and ultimately, cortical size. The mechanisms that regulate this progression are poorly understood (Elias et al., 2008; Mérot et al., 2009; Subramanian and Tole, 2009; Lui et al., 2011). However, mutations have been found in genes regulating the progenitor cell mitotic cycle in several types of severe congenital microcephaly (Thornton and Woods, 2009; Yu et al., 2010; Castiel et al., 2011; Kalay et al., 2011). Further, human microcephaly syndromes can be classified, to some degree, by the affected cell cycle phase (Supplementary Table 1).

Understanding of cell proliferation has been aided by the discovery that the primate subventricular zone is complex, composed of an outer subventricular zone, a layer of radially oriented neurons that is divided from the underlying subventricular zone by an ‘inner fibre layer’ that is presumably composed of corticocortical, corticothalamic and thalamocortical axons (Smart et al., 2002; Zecevic et al., 2005). Large numbers of radial glial-like cells and intermediate progenitor cells populate the human outer subventricular zone. The radial glial-like cells are non-epithelial, as they lack contact with the neuroependyma of the ventricular surface (Hansen et al., 2010), but still undergo both symmetric and self-renewing asymmetric divisions that allow further proliferation (Hansen et al., 2010). The expansive proliferation of progenitor cells in the outer subventricular zone helps to explain the evolutionary expansion of the number of radial glial units, surface area and gyrification in the primate cortex, as these later-born cells are presumed to occupy the outer cortical layers (Zecevic et al., 2005; Lui et al., 2011).

Recent advances in the genetics of cortical development

Progress has been made in understanding neuronal migration at the intracellular level (Heng et al., 2008; Nóbrega-Pereira et al., 2008; Stanco et al., 2009; Marin et al., 2010). As the importance of microtubule transport, centrosomal positioning, nuclear transport (associated with LIS1), microtubule stabilization (associated with DCX), vesicle trafficking and fusion (ARFGEF2 and FLNA), and neuroependymal integrity (MEKK4 and FLNA) in neuronal migration are well known (Wynshaw-Boris, 2007; Ferland et al., 2009; Pramparo et al., 2010), it was not surprising that mutations affecting microtubule proteins TUBA1A, TUBA8, TUBB2B and TUBB3 are associated with abnormal neuronal migration (lissencephaly) and postmigrational development (polymicrogyria or polymicrogyria-like dysplasias) (Poirier et al., 2007; Abdollahi et al., 2009; Jaglin and Chelly, 2009; Kumar et al., 2010; Poirier et al., 2010). Many genes linked to several pathways are known to regulate neuronal migration, but the mechanisms are poorly understood. Knockdown of some genes (such as Rnd2) result in migration defects that are identical to those observed with deletions of others (such as Neurog2) (Heng et al., 2008). Proteins that function in anchoring of the radial glial cells to the ventricular epithelium (such as BIG2; Ferland et al., 2009) or to the pial limiting membrane (such as GPR56; Luo et al., 2011) affect migration in a manner similar to those that directly affect migration. Clearly, any classification based upon these genes will require changes as the mechanisms of action of their protein products are elucidated.

The processes that direct postmitotic neurons in the ventricular and subventricular zones are being elucidated. In mice, neurons in the medial ganglionic eminences migrate to the striatum because Nkx2-1 (human NKX2.1 or TITF1) regulates expression of neuropilin-2, a guidance receptor that enables interneurons to enter the developing striatum. When Nkx2-1 is downregulated, interneurons are repulsed by class 3 semaphorins and bypass the striatum, migrating instead to the cortex (Nóbrega-Pereira et al., 2008; Hernández-Miranda et al., 2011). The laminar fate of neurons is determined in progenitor cells prior to their final mitosis. Early cortical progenitors are competent to generate late-born neurons after transplantation into older hosts, indicating that they can respond to later environmental cues, but progenitors become progressively restricted in their ability to populate different lamina as neurogenesis proceeds (Lui et al., 2011). Neuronal genes that correlate with their layer-specific neuronal identity are selectively expressed by cortical progenitors. Many continue to be expressed in their progeny (Chen et al., 2008; Lai et al., 2008), and some exhibit very high laminar specificity in the cortex in both animals and humans. Examples include Ror-beta (in 50% of layer IV neurons), Er81 (in 31% of layer V neurons) and Nurr1 in layer VI (Hevner, 2007; Garbelli et al., 2009).

Newborn projection neurons pause in the subventricular zone for up to 24 h before initiating radial migration, suggesting that the subventricular zone constitutes a unique ‘permissive’ environment for synchronizing migration by projection neurons and interneurons generated at the same time, thereby giving them their appropriate laminar identity (Mérot et al., 2009; Lui et al., 2011). In contrast, late cortical progenitors generate only upper layer neurons, even when transplanted into the more permissive environment of younger embryos (Lui et al., 2011). Thus, the expression of many early neural genes appears to be ‘turned off’ as neurogenesis proceeds. These factors may provide clues to genes and pathways underlying malformations of abnormal postmigrational development (formerly malformations of cortical organization) such as polymicrogyria. Misspecification of projection, commissural and association neurons could potentially underlie disorders of sensorimotor or visual function, commissuration or cognition, respectively.

The developing leptomeninges affect multiple stages of cortical development. For example, retinoic acid produced in the leptomeninges regulates the generation of cortical neurons (Siegenthaler et al., 2009). Tangential migration of cortical hem-derived Cajal–Retzius cells, which play an important role in termination of neuronal migration to the cortex, is controlled by the leptomeninges via CXCL12/CXCR4 signalling (Borrell and Marin, 2006). The leptomeninges are also essential for the survival of radial glial cells, which undergo apoptotic cell death if the meninges are removed (Radokovits et al., 2009). Finally, the leptomeninges play an important role in maintaining the cerebral basement membrane. Loss of Zic activity reduces proliferation of meningeal cells, resulting in a thin and disrupted pial basement membrane in mouse models (Inoue et al., 2008). Reduction of Foxc1 activity in the leptomeninges impairs the ability of the basement membrane to expand in conjunction with brain growth, resulting in lamination defects, neuronal overmigration and subpial heterotopia formation (Hecht et al., 2010). Thus, abnormal leptomeningeal development may result in cortical dysgenesis via multiple mechanisms.

Discussion and rationale for changes in new classification

Mutations of many genes have been newly described in patients with malformations of cortical development and these, along with the new advances concerning normal development discussed in the previous section, form the basis for this update. The overall framework of the classification remains largely the same (Appendix 1 and Supplementary Table 2) making it useful in everyday practice, while providing a theoretical basis for posing of academic questions. Group I remains ‘Malformations secondary to abnormal neuronal and glial proliferation or apoptosis’ and Group II remains ‘Malformations Secondary to Abnormal Neuronal Migration’. The name of Group III has been changed from ‘Malformations secondary to abnormal cortical organization’ to ‘Malformations secondary to Abnormal Postmigrational Development’, as the process of cortical organization begins before the termination of neuronal migration. Another structural change is that Group IV, ‘Malformations of cortical development, Not otherwise classified’, has been eliminated and the disorders previously listed there have been moved. A third change is that disorders are classified according to their mode of inheritance (autosomal recessive, autosomal dominant, X-linked, polygenic in rare cases, etc.) and whether the disorder is clinically or genetically defined. This change should help clinicians classify their patients more easily, particularly in complicated disorders such as microcephalies. One concern is that the division into genetically defined and clinically defined disorders moves the classification, at least partially, from one based upon underlying mechanisms to one based upon current understanding. With the proliferation of gene discovery, it has become clear that different mutations of the same gene can result in completely different syndromes; thus, disorders defined by gene alone quickly become excessive and confusing. The optimal classification will not be based on genes but pathways and mechanism of protein action, with variations based on how the specific gene mutation alters protein function in the affected pathway. Clinically defined disorders may rapidly become obsolete. However, our current understanding of pathways and mechanisms of protein action is not adequate to classify disorders on that basis, while genetic knowledge has advanced to the point where the old classification was becoming less useful. This revision can be viewed as an intermediate system that should prove useful while the foundations of the pathway-based classification are constructed. Genes, genetic loci and references for each disorder are in Appendix 1. The references should make Appendix 1 more useful to clinicians trying to make a diagnosis. Some disorders in Appendix 1 have no associated reference, either because they are well known and can be accessed in any textbook (such as ganglioglioma or isolated periventricular nodular heterotopia), or because the specific entities are not published, but have been identified as specific entities by the authors.

Group I: malformations secondary to abnormal neuronal and glial proliferation or apoptosis

This group continues to be separated into three categories: reduced proliferation or accelerated apoptosis (congenital microcephalies); increased proliferation or decreased apoptosis (megalencephalies); and abnormal proliferation (focal and diffuse dysgenesis and dysplasia).

Groups I.A and III.D: microcephaly

Most genes known to cause primary microcephaly (Appendix 1) affect pathways involving neurogenesis: transcription regulation (MCPH1, CENPJ, CDK5RAP2; Thornton and Woods, 2009), cell cycle progression and checkpoint regulation (MCPH1, CENPJ, CDK5RAP2; Thornton and Woods, 2009), centrosome maturation (CDK5RAP2 and CENPJ; Thornton and Woods, 2009), dynein binding and centrosome duplication (NDE1; Alkuraya et al., 2011; Bakircioglu et al., 2011), DNA repair (MCPH1; Thornton and Woods, 2009), progenitor proliferative capacity (ASPM and STIL; Desir et al., 2008; Kumar et al., 2009; Passemard et al., 2009), interference with mitotic spindle formation [WDR62 (Bilgüvar et al., 2010; Yu et al., 2010) and NDE1 (Feng and Walsh, 2004)] and DNA repair deficit [PNKP (Shen et al., 2010) and PCNT (Griffith et al., 2008)]. These pathways affect processes—alterations of cell cycle length, spindle positioning or DNA repair efficiency—that affect neurogenesis and, in particular, the cell cycle phases of mitosis (Supplementary Table 1). WDR62, ASPM and STIL are spindle pole proteins, suggesting that focused spindle poles are of great significance in neural progenitor cell division. Spindle poles attach to mature centrosomes; they control the position of the central spindle and, hence, the direction of the last stage of the cytokinesis cleavage furrow (Nicholas et al., 2010). If cell division is perfectly symmetric, it produces two daughter cell neural precursors. If not, the daughter cell may fail to inherit a part of the cadherin hole; as a result, it differentiates into a neuron, becomes postmitotic, and migrates out of the neuroepithelium (Nicholas et al., 2010). Microcephaly secondary to mutations of WDR62 has associated cortical malformations (Yu et al., 2010). Mutations of ARFGEF2 have associated periventricular nodular heterotopia (de Wit et al., 2009) and some individuals with microcephalic osteodysplastic primordial dwarfism have cortical dysgenesis (Juric-Sekhar et al., 2011). Mutations of other primary microcephaly genes described so far do not have obvious brain anomalies other than simplification of the gyral pattern and hypoplasia of the corpus callosum (Passemard et al., 2009; Rimol et al., 2010; Shen et al., 2010), although few have had pathological analyses. No definable clinico-radiological characteristics have been identified that separate microcephalies caused by mutations affecting different parts of the mitotic cycle. Although no human microcephaly syndromes have yet been described in association with excessive developmental neuron apoptosis, AMSH-deficient mice have been shown to have postmigrational microcephaly due to increased developmental neuronal death (Ishii et al., 2001). Overall, a great deal of progress has been made in the understanding of genetic causes of microcephaly but not enough to justify a purely genetic- or pathway-based classification. Therefore, for the current classification, microcephalies are classified based upon inheritance, associated clinical features, and causative gene.

Patients born with normal to slightly small head size (2 standard deviations or less below mean) and developing severe microcephaly in the first 1–2 years after birth form a separate group designated postmigrational microcephaly (now listed in Group III), because brain growth seems to slow during late gestation or the early postnatal period after normal early development. X-linked postmigrational microcephaly associated with mutations of CASK is placed in this group; this disorder is seen in girls with mental retardation, short stature, and disproportionate cerebellar and brainstem hypoplasia (Najm et al., 2008; Takanashi et al., 2010). Also in this group are pontocerebellar hypoplasias due to mutations in transfer RNA splicing endonuclease subunit genes (TSEN54, TSEN2, TSEN34), prenatal onset neurodegenerative disorders in which significant microcephaly develops after birth (Barth et al., 2007; Namavar et al., 2011). Also in this group is microcephaly due to mutations or genomic deletions of FOXG1, sometimes described as a congenital variant of Rett syndrome (Kortüm et al., 2011). The processes that interfere with normal brain development in late gestation or the early postnatal period are not understood. With the disruption of normal brain development occurring late, these disorders may be good candidates for intervention once the molecular cause of the disorder is understood.

Group I.B: megalencephalies

As reasons for megalencephaly are not established in many disorders in this group, many are clinically defined, even if the mutated gene is known. Megalencephaly is seen in 6% of patients with polymicrogyria (Leventer et al., 2010). These megalencephalic polymicrogyria syndromes have been named macrocephaly, polymicrogyria, polydactyly, hydrocephalus (MPPH) (Mirzaa et al., 2004), Macrocephaly–Cutis Marmorata Telangiectata Congenita (M-CMTC) and the Macrocephaly Capillary Malformation (MCAP) syndromes (Conway et al., 2007; Tore et al., 2009). Nearly all of these patients have some sort of cortical malformation; most have perisylvian polymicrogyria, but the polymicrogyria may be more widely scattered and is sometimes more severe over the convexities. Progressive tonsillar ectopia (herniation) is characteristic. Until the different entities are sorted out, we have chosen to list all patients with polymicrogyria and macrocephaly within a single group, called MCAP (megalencephaly capillary malformation-polymicrogyria). Further subcategories will likely be established based upon genetic findings and associated anomalies.

Hemimegalencephaly is not included in this group because of the presence of abnormal (dysmorphic) cells in that disorder (Flores-Sarnat et al., 2003).

Group I.C: cortical dysgeneses with abnormal cell proliferation

An important advance in understanding cell proliferation has been the elucidation of specific molecular pathways that control proliferation, in particular the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) pathway, which is important in abnormal cerebral cortical development (as well as renal, cardiac and pulmonary development) of the tuberous sclerosis complex (Crino et al., 2006). The tuberous sclerosis complex1–tuberous sclerosis complex2 protein complex integrates cues from growth factors, the cell cycle and nutrients to regulate the activity of mTOR, p70S6 kinase (S6K), 4E-BP1 and ribosomal S6 proteins. A number of groups have contributed to work showing that mutations leading to loss of function of the tuberous sclerosis complex1 or tuberous sclerosis complex2 genes result in enhanced Rheb-GTP signalling and consequent mTOR activation, causing increased cell growth, ribosome biogenesis and messenger RNA translation; ultimately, the result is overgrowth of normal cells and production of abnormal cells in many organs (Crino et al., 2006). This discovery has had significant therapeutic implications in managing cerebral, visceral and cognitive disorders associated with tuberous sclerosis (de Vries, 2010).

A major change in this group has been the proposal of a new classification of FCDs, a heterogeneous group of disorders that commonly cause medically refractory epilepsy in children (Taylor et al., 1971; Blümcke et al., 2011). FCDs are very likely to have many aetiologies (Krsek et al., 2010; Orlova et al., 2010; Blümcke et al., 2011). The new classification and several other works support the classification of FCD type II (FCDII) as a malformation due to abnormal proliferation. Histological characteristics of FCDII are fairly consistent across affected patients and it is likely to be a much more homogeneous disorder than FCDI or the new FCDIII (both discussed in the ‘Group III: Malformations secondary to abnormal postmigrational development’ section). Several groups have demonstrated that FCDI and FCDII cells (neurons and balloon cells) express different proteins at different cortical layers (Hadjivassiliou et al., 2010; Orlova et al., 2010). The protein phenotype of cells found in FCDII is similar to that seen in tubers of the tuberous sclerosis complex, justifying their classification together; both have progenitor proteins that appear early in development, are present in deep cell layers, and are similar to those found in multipotent or pluripotent stem cells. In contrast, cells from FCDI express few early proteins (Hadjivassiliou et al., 2010; Orlova et al., 2010) and those expressed are found in more superficial layers (junction of layers I and II) (Hadjivassiliou et al., 2010). Other studies (Yasin et al., 2010; Han et al., 2011) suggest that balloon cells in patients with FCDII originate from glioneuronal progenitor cells, strongly suggesting that defects of neuronal and glial specifications are important in the histogenesis of FCDII. These findings support the concept that cells of FCDII derive from radial glial progenitors (Lamparello et al., 2007) and may support the ‘dysmature cerebral developmental hypothesis’ that seizures in some forms of FCD may be the result of interactions of dysmature cells with normal postnatal ones (Cepeda et al., 2006). Focal transmantle dysplasia (Barkovich et al., 1997) and bottom of sulcus dysplasia (Hofman et al., 2011), described as specific types of cortical dysplasia based on imaging features, have histological features of FCDIIb and are likely different names for the same entity (Krsek et al., 2010). They have excellent outcomes after surgical resection, probably because their presence and location are easily identified by imaging (Krsek et al., 2010).

Several authors have made the observation that hemimegalencephaly has increased cell densities in the outer cortical layers and white matter of the affected hemisphere, but decreased cell densities in the inner cortical layers (Salamon et al., 2006; Mathern et al., 2007). MRI studies showed that the non-affected hemisphere was smaller than hemispheres of age-matched normal subjects, resulting in the suggestion that somatic mutations affect each developing cerebral hemisphere differently (Salamon et al., 2006), possibly due to incomplete apoptosis (Mathern et al., 2007). The abnormal contralateral hemisphere may explain the poorer than expected post-surgery seizure control and cognitive outcomes (Salamon et al., 2006; Mathern et al., 2007). Hemimegalencephaly is divided into three categories because the appearance of hemimegalencephaly associated with tuberous sclerosis is one of multiple tubers in a single hemisphere (Griffiths et al., 1998; Galluzzi et al., 2002; Parmar et al., 2003), rather than the more diffuse process involving a variable portion of a hemisphere, seen in other neurocutaneous disorders and in isolated hemimegalencephaly. This classification will need to be re-evaluated as more cases are carefully analysed.

Group II: malformations due to abnormal neuronal migration

Several studies have shown that abnormalities of the neuroependyma (ventricular epithelium) are associated with periventricular nodular heterotopia (Ferland et al., 2009). Group II has, therefore, been divided into four subcategories: malformations resulting from abnormalities of the neuroependymal (initiation of migration), mainly including periventricular heterotopia; generalized abnormalities of transmantle migration, mainly including lissencephalies; localized abnormalities of transmantle migration, mainly subcortical heterotopia; and abnormalities due to abnormal terminal migration/defects in pial limiting membrane. The latter group now consists mostly of cobblestone malformations, although less severe forms of these have been defined in foetal alcohol syndrome and in mice with mutations of some transcription factors such as Foxc1 (Zarbalis et al., 2007).

Group II.A: heterotopia

Macroscopic collections of heterotopic neurons come in many forms and sizes, ranging from periventricular nodular heterotopia, the most common form, to periventricular linear heterotopia, consisting of a smooth layer of grey matter lining the ventricular wall, to columnar heterotopia, a linearly arranged collection of neurons that span the cerebral mantle from the pia to the ependyma, to large subcortical heterotopia that consist of curvilinear swirls of grey matter originating from deep sulci, which wind their way through the cerebral mantle to the ependyma. Little is known about the genetic and embryological causes of the more complex heterotopia. As the neurons are deposited everywhere between the ventricle and the pia in these disorders, they remain classified as malformations due to abnormal neuron migration. However, as periventricular nodular heterotopia appears to have a different embryogenesis than other heterotopia, and many have known genetic causes, they have been separated from the others and placed in the subcategory of malformations with neuroependymal abnormalities (Group II.A).

Ferland et al. (2009) showed that injury to, or denudation of, the neuroependyma (ventricular zone epithelium) is likely an important factor in the formation of periventricular nodular heterotopia (rather than a cell-intrinsic motility defect. This observation clarifies why periventricular nodular heterotopia is caused by ARFGEF1 mutations even though its protein product (BIG2) is not involved in neuronal migration (Ferland et al., 2009). Similar to subpial heterotopia in cobblestone malformations, which result from a loss of structural integrity of the pial limiting membrane (Yamamoto et al., 2004; Luo et al., 2011), the denuded ventricular epithelium in periventricular nodular heterotopia may cause disengagement of radial glia, resulting in an inability of young neurons to migrate away (Ferland et al., 2009). Neurons in periventricular nodular heterotopia seem to be arranged in a layered pattern (Garbelli et al., 2009); analysis of layer-specific genes suggests that the outer layer of neurons in the nodule is composed of layer 6 neurons (expressing Rorβ), with the next layer being composed of layer 5 (expressing Er81) and the next for layer 4 (expressing Nurr1) (Garbelli et al., 2009). Compared with controls, fewer cells in the overlying cortex expressed these three genes in the appropriate layers, suggesting that late migrating neurons are less affected (Garbelli et al., 2009).

Group II.B: lissencephaly

Malformations due to widespread abnormal transmantle migration including agyria, pachygyria and subcortical band heterotopia, are all part of the lissencephaly spectrum. A major change in this group has come from the discovery that mutations of TUBA1A are responsible for 1–4% of classic (four-layered, with a cell-sparse zone) lissencephalies (Morris-Rosendahl et al., 2008; Kumar et al., 2010) and 30% of lissencephalies with cerebellar hypoplasia (Kumar et al., 2010). The TUBA1A-associated classic lissencephalies can have a wide range of dysgenesis involving the cortex, corpus callosum, basal ganglia/white matter and mid/hindbrain (Kumar et al., 2010). Patients with TUBA1A-associated classic lissencephaly have either p.R402C mutations, resulting in frontal pachygyria and posterior agyria with a cell-sparse zone, or p.R402H mutations, resulting in nearly complete agyria; both of these phenotypes are essentially identical to those associated with LIS1 mutations (Kumar et al., 2010), suggesting involvement of the same molecular pathways. Other groups with TUBA1A-associated lissencephaly had variant lissencephaly with heterogeneous missense mutations throughout the gene resulting in cortical dysgenesis varying from diffuse, often asymmetric, pachygyria with moderately thick cortex to a smooth, relatively thin cortex associated with diminution of cerebral white matter (Kumar et al., 2010). These phenotypes had absent or nearly absent corpus callosum, thin brainstem and severe cerebellar hypoplasia; callosal and mid-hindbrain malformations were most severe in the patients with thinner cerebral cortex (Kumar et al., 2010). Some patients have upward rotation of the cerebellar vermis with a dilated fourth ventricle and enlarged posterior fossa, fulfilling the criteria for Dandy–Walker malformation (Kumar et al., 2010). In our prior classification, these phenotypes were listed as variant lissencephaly with extreme microcephaly, absent (or nearly absent) corpus callosum, moderate to severe cerebellar hypoplasia and brainstem hypoplasia; they are likely the malformation that Forman et al. (2005) called ‘two layer lissencephaly’. The clinical phenotypes caused by mutations of TUBA1A also vary considerably; however, most affected patients have congenital microcephaly, mental retardation and severe neurodevelopmental delay with di/tetraplegia (Bahi-Buisson et al., 2008).

Group II.C: subcortical heterotopia and sublobar dysplasia

Subcortical heterotopia are poorly understood malformations in which large collections of neurons are found regionally in the deep cerebral white matter (Barkovich, 2000). Some are transmantle, composed of linear (columnar heterotopia) or curvilinear, swirling nodules of neurons continuous from the ependyma to the cortex. Others are composed of multiple nodules of neurons localized to the deep cerebral white matter. In all, the involved portion of the affected hemisphere is abnormally small and the overlying cortex appears thin, and sometimes, microgyric. The histology and embryogenesis of these disorders is unknown, but they are presumably due to localized abnormal late migration.

Also included in this category is sublobar dysplasia, a very rare malformation characterized by a region of dysmorphic brain within an otherwise normal-appearing hemisphere (Barkovich and Peacock, 1998). Histopathology, recently reported in a single patient, showed leptomeningeal and subcortical heterotopia, disturbance of cortical lamination, and marked cortical and subcortical astrocytosis, but no dysmorphic cells (Tuxhorn et al., 2009). As the early of these features correspond to abnormal cell migration, this disorder was moved to Group II.C.

Group II.D: cobblestone malformations

It has become clear that mutations of any genes involved in O-glycosylation of α-dystroglycan can cause a wide range of disorders ranging from Walker–Warburg syndrome to muscle–eye–brain disease to Fukuyama congenital muscular dystrophy to congenital muscular dystrophy types 1C and 1D to limb-girdle (LGMD2I, LGMD2K, LGMD2M) muscular dystrophies (Barresi and Campbell, 2006; Godfrey et al., 2007; Clement et al., 2008; Hewitt, 2009; van Reeuwijk et al., 2010). The precise molecular mechanisms underlying these phenotypic variations are slowly being elucidated (Hewitt, 2009; Ackroyd et al., 2011; Luo et al., 2011). The cause of the muscular, ocular or brain disorders in these patients is defective formation of basement membranes (of skeletal muscle, retina and cerebrum/cerebellum, respectively), which is related to impaired linkage of radial glia to the pial basement membrane, which is, in turn, dependent upon O-mannosylation of α-dystroglycan (Barresi and Campbell, 2006; Hewitt, 2009), laminin α1 deposition (Ackroyd et al., 2011) and GPR56-collagen III interactions (Luo et al., 2011). Resulting deficiencies in the cerebral basement membranes result in impaired anchorage of radial glial cells to the basement membranes, causing abnormal cortical lamination and overmigration of neurons through the incomplete basement membrane into the pial layer (Li et al., 2008; Luo et al., 2011). Less severe mutations may partially allow development of basement membranes and result in a less severe phenotype (Barresi and Campbell, 2006; van Reeuwijk et al., 2010; Luo et al., 2011; Yis et al., 2011). No direct correlation has been found between the severity of clinical disease and the particular gene mutation; however, null mutations of nearly all causative glycosylation genes result in severe (Walker–Warburg syndrome) phenotypes (except for POMGnT1) (van Reeuwijk et al., 2010). Much recent work has focused on cobblestone malformations due to Gpr56 and Col4a1 mutations (Li et al., 2008; Luo et al., 2011) and malformations associated with several genes affecting glycosylation within the endoplasmic reticulum or Golgi apparatus (classified as congenital disorders of glycosylation). Concerning the latter, the two best documented disorders to date are SRD5A3 (Al-Gazali et al., 2008; Cantagrel et al., 2010) and ATP6V0A2 (Kornak et al., 2008; Van Maldergem et al., 2008). GPR56 mutations appear to cause a ‘cobblestone cortex’ and not true polymicrogyria (Piao et al., 2005; Bahi-Buisson et al., 2010); therefore, the term ‘frontoparietal polymicrogyria’, which was the original name given to the cortical malformations seen in patients with GPR56 mutations, would be better replaced with a more appropriate one, such as ‘frontal-predominant cobblestone malformation’. The cortical malformation associated with TUBB2B mutations also has cobblestone-like features including overmigration of neurons through gaps in the leptomeninges (Jaglin et al., 2009). Its proper classification awaits further study, but it is currently classified in Group III.A.3, syndromes with polymicrogyria, the neuropathology of which may differ from classic polymicrogyria.

Group III: malformations secondary to abnormal postmigrational development

Group III.A: polymicrogyria and schizencephaly

Polymicrogyria has been known for many years to be a spectrum of disorders classified under a single name and many discussions of ‘true’ polymicrogyria and variants of microgyria have appeared in the literature (Volpe and Adams, 1972; Evrard et al., 1989; Barkovich, 2010a). However, the term is still widely used to describe disorders that have different causes, somewhat different gross appearance, association with different accompanying malformations or disruptions, and different microscopic appearance, making it difficult to understand and properly classify the disorders (Judkins et al., 2011). Polymicrogyria has been described in conjunction with many genetic disorders (listed in Appendix 1, Group III.A.3). Unfortunately, little is understood of the range of histopathology seen in polymicrogyria, partly because few large scale pathological studies have been performed. The paucity of pathological data stems from polymicrogyria often being located in eloquent cortical areas; thus, it is rarely resected when causing intractable epilepsy (Leventer et al., 2010). Recent studies suggest a great deal of heterogeneity in the gross (Barkovich, 2010b; Leventer et al., 2010) and microscopic (Judkins et al., 2011) appearance of polymicrogyria, supporting the concept that polymicrogyria is heterogeneous in cause, embryogenesis and gross characteristics. In addition, it has been speculated that the underlying mechanisms by which polymicrogyria develops in patients with mutations and infections may be vascular (Robin et al., 2006). Many authors describe malformations resulting from disruption of the radial glial fibre attachment to the pial limiting membrane and the consequent gaps in that membrane as polymicrogyria (Jaglin and Chelly, 2009), but (as discussed in the previous section) others believe that cortical malformations associated with pial membrane defects are distinct from polymicrogyria and are better classified as cobblestone malformations (Jansen and Andermann, 2005; Leventer et al., 2010; Judkins et al., 2011). To determine the mechanisms leading to polymicrogyria, a first step will be to perform histological and molecular studies on resected tissue or autopsy specimens, in addition to developing appropriate animal models, before the differences among the many patterns can be understood.

In this classification, we have put polymicrogyria into four groups: Group III.A. with schizencephalic clefts or calcifications, presumably due to infection or vascular causes; Group III.B. without clefts or calcifications, which may be genetic or disruptive; Group III.C. as part of genetically defined multiple congenital anomaly syndromes (some of these have atypical histology); and Group III.D. in conjunction with inborn errors of metabolism (these also have atypical histology). These groups should be refined as new studies of the pathology and pathogenesis of polymicrogyria are performed.

Although past work suggested that mutations of EMX2 are a common cause of schizencephaly (Granata et al., 1997), recent work has shown that EMX2 mutations are highly unlikely to be a cause of schizencephaly (Tietjen et al., 2007; Merello et al., 2008); the authors recommend against testing for this gene, as the results would be uninterpretable. Furthermore, a large population study of <4 million births in California from 1984 to 2001 found an association with young maternal age and with monozygotic twin pregnancies (Curry et al., 2005). One-third of cases had a non-CNS abnormality, over half of which could be classified as secondary to vascular disruption (including gastroschisis, bowel atresias and amniotic band syndrome) (Curry et al., 2005). The authors concluded that schizencephaly is a disorder with heterogeneous causes, many of which are vascular disruptive in origin (Curry et al., 2005). It is unquestionably associated with polymicrogyria of disruptive aetiology. Accordingly, it is classified in Group III.A and by clinical characteristics.

Group III.C: focal cortical dysplasias

Certain FCDs are classified as ‘Malformations secondary to abnormal postmigrational development’ because evidence supports proposals that they can result from injury to the cortex during later stages of cortical development. Evidence has been published that prenatal and perinatal insults including severe prematurity, asphyxia, shaking injury, bleeding, hydrocephalus and stroke, occur in children with mild malformation of cortical development or FCDI (Marin-Padilla et al., 2002; Krsek et al., 2010). Patients with significant prenatal and perinatal risk factors had more abnormal neurological findings, lower IQ scores, and slower background EEG activity than subjects with mild malformation of cortical development/FCD without prenatal or perinatal brain injury (Krsek et al., 2010). As FCDIII are, by definition, associated with injury, vascular malformation or epileptogenic tumour, it is very possible that FCDIII are caused by seizures or by the lesion causing the seizures. A subtype of FCDI has increased neuronal densities and decreased cortical thickness, with an abundance of cortical microcolumns (Blümcke et al., 2010); the affected hemisphere is significantly smaller than the non-epileptogenic contralateral side. These observations support the concept that FCDI is a heterogeneous group of disorders that may result from late insult/injury to the developing cortex.

Group III.D: postmigrational microcephaly

Postmigrational microcephaly and the rationale for placing it in this section was discussed in the earlier ‘Microcephaly’ section.

Conclusion

In order to retain its utility for the clinician and physician scientist, both the framework and the content of this classification of Malformations of Cortical Development have been updated based upon recent scientific and clinical advances. Although complexity of this classification has increased, making it more cumbersome, accurate diagnoses are essential for both clinical and genetic counselling; thus, the authors believe that this level of complexity is currently necessary. Further updates (and, hopefully, simplification) will be required as information accumulates about the clinical, embryological, genetic and molecular biological aspects of these disorders. Unfortunately despite the many discoveries in genetics, advances in this field have been slowed by the limited access to human brain specimens for developmental neuropathology studies, such as cell lineage, gene expression and searches for somatic mosaicism, upon rare malformation of cortical developments. FCD is the exception, and this can be attributed to the flourishing of epilepsy surgery programmes. However, limited resources appear to be available for classical developmental neuropathology, with inadequate networks to facilitate access to post-mortem brain tissue containing malformations of cortical development. Hopefully, such an organization can be developed, and our knowledge will quickly increase to the point where these disorders are grouped according to the affected pathways; the tasks of both future authors and their readers will thereby be simplified.

Funding

Unite States National Institutes of Health under NINDS grant NS058721 (Dobyns)

Supplementary material

Supplementary material is available at Brain online.

Appendix

  1. MALFORMATIONS SECONDARY TO ABNORMAL NEURONAL AND GLIAL PROLIFERATION OR APOPTOSIS

    • A. SEVERE CONGENITAL MICROCEPHALY (MIC), pre-migrational reduced proliferation or excess apoptosis

      1. MIC with severe IUGR deficiency and short stature

               Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        1. Seckel syndrome with unknown cause (Shanske et al., 1997)

        2. MOPD syndromes with unknown cause

        3. Other MIC-IUGR syndromes

        4. Seckel syndrome with mutations in ATR at 3q22–q24 (O'Driscoll et al., 2003)

        5. MOPD type 2 with mutations in PCNT at 21q22.3 (Rauch et al., 2008)

        6. MOPD type 1 with mutations in ORC1 at 1p32 (Bicknell et al., 2011)

        7. MOPD type 1 with mutations in ORC4 at 2q22-q23 (Guernsey et al., 2011)

        8. MOPD type 1 with mutations in ORC6 at 16q12 (Bernal and Venkitaraman, 2011)

        9. MOPD type 1 with mutations in CDT1 at 16q24.3 (Bicknell et al., 2011b)

        10. MOPD type 1 with mutations in CDC6 at 17q21.2 (Bicknell et al., 2011a)

      2. MIC with variable short stature (severe IUGR to mildly short), moderate to severe DD/ID, normal to thin cortex, SIMP, with/without callosal hypogenesis

        Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        1. Seckel syndrome or AR primary microcephaly (MCPH) with mutations in CENPJ at 13q12.12 (Al-Dosari et al., 2010)

        2. Seckel syndrome or MCPH with mutations in CEP152 at 15q21.1 (Kalay et al., 2011)

      3. MIC with mildly short stature or normal growth, mild-moderate DD/ID, normal to thin cortex, with/without SIMP, with/without callosal hypogenesis and with/without focal PNH

        Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        1. AR primary microcephaly (MCPH) (Woods et al., 2005) Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        2. MCPH with mutations in ASPM at 1q31.3 (Bond et al., 2003; Shen et al., 2005; Desir et al., 2008)

        3. MCPH with mutations in MCPH1 at 8p23.1 (Trimborn et al., 2004; Darvish et al., 2010)

        4. MCPH with mutations in CDKRAP5 (Bond et al., 2005; W.B.D., in preparation)

        5. MCPH with mutations in STIL at 1p33 (Kumar et al., 2009)

      4. MIC with mildly short stature or normal growth, severe DD/ID, variable cortical development with SIMP or cortical dysgenesis and with/without ACC (includes genes with spectrum from SIMP to dysgenetic cortex or PMG)

        Clinically defined with AR or XL inheritance

        1. MIC with diffuse PMG

        2. MIC with asymmetric PMG

        3. MIC with atypical cortical dysgenesis

          Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        4. MCPH with mutations in PNKP at 19q13.33 (Shen et al., 2010)

        5. MCPH, MIC with diffuse PMG (MDP) or MIC with asymmetric PMG (MAP) with mutations in WDR62 at 19q13.12 (Bilgüvar et al., 2010; Yu et al., 2010)

        6. MCPH, MDP (other cortical malformation) with mutations in NDE1 at 16p13.11 (Alkuraya et al., 2011; Bakircioglu et al., 2011)

        7. MDP–MAP and ACC with mutations of TBR2 (EOMES) at 3p24.1 (Baala et al., 2007)

      5. MIC with variable anomalies and less well characterized syndromes; with/without SIMP; with/without PNH, with/without CBLH

        Clinically defined with probable AR inheritance

        1. MIC with diffuse periventricular nodular heterotopia

        2. MIC with disproportionate cerebellar hypoplasia

        3. MIC (extreme) with jejunal atresia (Stromme et al., 1993)

          Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        4. MIC–PNH associated with mutations in ARFGEF2 at 20q13.13 (Sheen et al., 2004; de Wit et al., 2009)

      6. MIC with severe DD/ID and evidence of degeneration, with/without mildly short stature, with/without enlarged extra-axial spaces, with/without ACC, with/without atypical cortical dysgenesis

        Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        1. MIC with enlarged extra-axial space

        2. MIC with enlarged extra-axial spaces and disproportionate cerebellar hypoplasia

        3. MIC due to foetal brain disruption with unknown cause

          Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        4. Amish lethal microcephaly associated with mutations in SLC25A19 at 17q25.1 (Rosenberg et al., 2002)

        5. MIC-capillary malformation syndrome (mutations in pending report)

      7. MIC with LIS (MLIS)—cortex thick or relatively thick, smooth white–grey border

               Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        1. Barth MLIS syndrome

        2. Norman–Roberts MLIS syndrome

        3. MOPD1 variant with three-layer lissencephaly (Juric-Sekhar et al., 2011)

        4. MIC with lissencephaly, CBLH and Hirschsprung disease

      8. MIC with tissue loss and enlarged ventricles (hydrocephalus ex vacuo or hydranencephaly), with/without cortical dysplasia and with/without ACC

               Clinically defined with presumed extrinsic (non-genetic) cause

        1. Foetal brain disruption sequence (Corona-Rivera et al., 2001)

                 Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        2. Familial foetal brain disruption-like syndrome with unknown cause

        3. Familial ‘microhydranencephaly’ with unknown cause (Behunova et al., 2010)

                 Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        4. Familial ‘microhydranencephaly’ associated with mutations of MHAC at 16p13.13–p12.2 (Kavaslar et al., 2000)

    • B. MEGALENCEPHALY (MEG) including both congenital and early postnatal

      1. MEG with normal cortex (or presumably normal cortex)

               Clinically defined with polygenic or AD inheritance

        1. Familial MEG

                 Genetically defined with AD inheritance

        2. Bannayan–Riley–Ruvalcaba syndrome, Cowden disease and MEG–autism with mutations in PTEN at 10q23.31 (Marsh et al., 1997; Marsh et al., 1999; Pilarski et al., 2011)

        3. Sotos syndrome with mutations in NSD1 at 5q35.2–q35.3 (Türkmen et al., 2003)

        4. DD/ID, autism with HEPACAM mutations at 11q24.2 (AD, homozygous mutations cause AR megalencephaly with leukoencephalopathy and cysts) (López-Hernández et al., 2011)

        5. MEG, thumb anomalies and Weaver-like dysmorphism with dup 2p24.3 (includes MYCN)

                 Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        6. MACS syndrome with mutations in RIN2 at 20p11.23 (Basel-Vanagaite et al., 2009)

                 Genetically defined with XL inheritance

        7. Simpson–Golabi–Behmel syndrome 1 with mutations in GPC3 at Xq26.2 (Pilia et al., 1996)

        8. Simpson–Golabi–Behmel syndrome 2 with mutations in OFD1 at Xp22.2 (Budny et al., 2006)

        9. MEG with DD/ID and seizures with mutations in RAB39B at Xq28 (Giannandrea et al., 2010)

                 Genetically defined with somatic mosaicism

        10. Proteus syndrome caused by somatic activating mutation in AKT1 at 14q32.33 (Lindhurst et al., 2011)

      2. MEG with PNH—plus other anomalies

               Clinically defined with AD or unknown inheritance

        1. MEG–PNH phenotype (Jan, 1999)

      3. MEG with PMG and other cortical dysgenesis

               Clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. MCAP syndrome, includes MPPH (Mirzaa et al., 2004; Conway et al., 2007)

        2. Thanatophoric dysplasia or Apert syndrome with mutation of FGFR3 at 4p16.3 (six-layered PMG-like cortex) (Hevner, 2005)

    • C. CORTICAL DYSGENESIS WITH ABNORMAL CELL PROLIFERATION BUT WITHOUT NEOPLASIA

      1. Diffuse cortical dysgenesis

               Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        1. PMSE syndrome with MEG, cortical dysgenesis including leptomeningeal glioneuronal heterotopia and cortical dyslamination with mutations in STRADA (LYK5) (Puffenberger et al., 2007)

      2. Focal and multifocal cortical and subcortical dysgenesis

               Clinically defined with putative postzygotic mosaicism

        1. HMEG isolated (Flores-Sarnat, 2002; Salamon et al., 2006; Mathern et al., 2007)

        2. HMEG with neurocutaneous syndromes (Flores-Sarnat, 2002)

        3. FCD Type II with large, dysmorphic neurons (FCDIIa) (Blümcke et al., 2011)

        4. FCD Type II with large, dysmorphic neurons and balloon cells (FCDIIb), including transmantle dysplasia and bottom of sulcus dysplasia (Blümcke et al., 2011)

                 Genetically defined with AD inheritance

        5. Tuberous sclerosis with cortical hamartomas and mutations of TSC1 at 9q34.13 (Jones et al., 1999; Crino et al., 2006)

        6. Tuberous sclerosis with cortical hamartomas and mutations of TSC2 at 16p13.3 (Jones et al., 1999; Crino et al., 2006)

        7. Tuberous sclerosis with HMEG (Galluzzi et al., 2002)

    • D. CORTICAL DYSPLASIAS WITH ABNORMAL CELL PROLIFERATION AND NEOPLASIA

      1. Neoplastic dysgenesis with primitive cells

        1. DNET

      2. Neoplastic dysgenesis with mature cells

        1. Ganglioglioma

        2. Gangliocytoma

  2. II. MALFORMATIONS DUE TO ABNORMAL NEURONAL MIGRATION

    • A. MALFORMATIONS WITH NEUROEPENDYMAL ABNORMALITIES: PERIVENTRICULAR HETEROTOPIA

      1. Anterior predominate and diffuse PNH

               Clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. Diffuse PNH with/without sparing of temporal horns

        2. Diffuse PNH composed of micronodules

        3. Diffuse PNH with frontonasal dysplasia (Guerrini and Dobyns, 1998)

        4. Anterior predominant PNH

        5. Anterior predominant PNH with fronto-perisylvian PMG (Wieck et al., 2005)

        6. Unilateral or bilateral isolated PNH

                 Genetically defined with AD inheritance (new mutations)

        7. Anterior PNH with duplication 5p15.1 (Sheen et al., 2003)

        8. Anterior or diffuse PNH with duplication 5p15.33 (Sheen et al., 2003)

        9. Diffuse (but variable) PNH with del 6q27 (W.B.D, in preparation)

        10. PNH and Williams syndrome with del 7q11.23, including HIP1 and YWHAG (Ferland et al., 2006; Ramocki et al., 2010)

        11. PNH with del 4p15 (gene not identified) (Gawlik-Kuklinska et al., 2008)

        12. PNH with deletion 5q14.3–q15 (Cardoso et al., 2009)

        13. PNH and agenesis of the corpus callosum with del 1p36.22-pter (Neal et al., 2006)

                 Genetically defined with XL inheritance

        14. Bilateral PNH due to mutations of FLNA, with/without Ehlers–Danlos (Sheen et al., 2001; Parrini et al., 2006)

        15. PNH and Fragile X syndrome (Moro et al., 2006)

      2. Posterior predominant (temporal-trigonal) PNH

               Clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. Posterior PNH only

        2. Posterior PNH with hippocampal dysgenesis, colpocephaly, anomalies of midbrain tectum or cerebellar hypoplasia

        3. Posterior PNH with posterior PMG (Wieck et al., 2005)

      3. Periventricular heterotopia, not nodular (unilateral or bilateral)

               Clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. Diffuse PLH

        2. Frontal predominant PLH

        3. Posterior predominant PLH

      4. Ribbon-like heterotopia, bilateral undulating heterotopic band

               Clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. Posterior predominant ribbon-like heterotopia

        2. Diffuse ribbon-like heterotopia

    • B. MALFORMATIONS DUE TO GENERALIZED ABNORMAL TRANSMANTLE MIGRATION (radial and non-radial)

      1. Anterior predominant or diffuse classic (four-layered) LIS and SBH

               Clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. Anterior predominant LIS with abrupt transition and cerebellar hypoplasia (previously LCHe)

        2. Anterior predominant or diffuse LIS (ILS)

                 Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        3. Anterior predominant LIS (ILS) with AR inheritance

        4. Winter–Tsukahara syndrome (Levin et al., 1993)

                 Clinically defined with AD (new mutation) inheritance

        5. Baraitser–Winter syndrome with anterior or diffuse LIS–SBH (Rossi et al., 2003)

        6. Anterior predominant LIS (ILS) or SBH with DCX mutation at Xq22.3–q23 (Dobyns et al., 1999)

      2. Posterior predominant or diffuse classic (four-layered) and two-layered (without cell-sparse zone) LIS and SBH

               Clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. Posterior predominant or diffuse LIS with brainstem and cerebellar hypoplasia, with/without ACC (includes former LCHa, LCHc, LCHd, LCHf (Ross et al., 2001))

        2. Posterior predominant or diffuse LIS (ILS) (Pilz et al., 1998, Dobyns et al., 1999)

        3. Diffuse LIS with hair and nail anomalies (Celentano et al., 2006)

        4. Perisylvian (central) pachygyria (ILS)

        5. Ribbon like deep white matter heterotopia with/without ACC, thin overlying cortex

                 Clinically defined with AD inheritance

        6. Posterior predominant SBH (Deconinck et al., 2003)

                 Genetically defined with AD inheritance (new mutation)

        7. Posterior or diffuse LIS with cerebellar hypoplasia or LIS (ILS) with TUBA1A mutations at 12q12-q14 (Poirier et al., 2007; Kumar et al., 2010)

        8. Miller-Dieker syndrome (four-layered) with deletion 17p13.3 (YWHAE to LIS1) (Dobyns et al., 1991)

        9. Posterior or diffuse LIS (ILS, four-layered) or posterior SBH with LIS1 deletions or mutations at 17p13.3 (Dobyns et al., 1993; Pilz et al., 1999)

      3. X-linked lissencephaly (three-layered, without cell-sparse zone) with callosal agenesis, ambiguous genitalia (XLAG)

               Clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. XLAG-like syndrome with temporal-posterior predominant LIS, ACC, microphthalmia and midline cleft lip and palate

        2. XLAG with temporal-posterior predominant LIS and ACC with mutations in ARX at Xp22.13 (Bonneau et al., 2002)

      4. Reelin-type LIS (inverted cortical lamination, without cell-sparse zone)

               Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        1. Frontal predominant mild LIS with severe hippocampal and CBLH (Kato et al., 1999)

                 Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        2. Frontal predominant mild LIS with severe hippocampal and CBLH with RELN mutation at 7q22 (Hong et al., 2000)

        3. Frontal predominant mild LIS with severe hippocampal and CBLH with VLDLR mutation at 9p24 (Boycott et al., 2005)

      5. Variant LIS (other rare types exist but are poorly characterized)

    • C. MALFORMATIONS PRESUMABLY DUE TO LOCALIZED ABNORMAL LATE RADIAL OR TANGENTIAL TRANSMANTLE MIGRATION

      1. Subcortical heterotopia (other than band heterotopia or cortical infolding), all clinically defined with unknown cause

        1. Curvilinear transmantle heterotopia, with thinning of overlying cortex, decreased volume of affected hemisphere, with/without ACC, with/without basal ganglia anomalies (Barkovich, 1996)

        2. Multinodular subcortical heterotopia with thin overlying cortex, with/without PMG (Barkovich, 2000)

        3. Transmantle columnar heterotopia with/without PNH

      2. Sublobar Dysplasia, clinically defined with unknown cause (Tuxhorn et al., 2009)

    • D. MALFORMATIONS DUE TO ABNORMAL TERMINAL MIGRATION AND DEFECTS IN PIAL LIMITING MEMBRANE

      1. Dystroglycan–laminin complex abnormalities with cobblestone malformation complex (COB), with or without congenital muscular dystrophy

         Clinically defined with AR inheritance but causative gene unknown

        1. Walker–Warburg syndrome (Dobyns et al., 1985, 1997)

        2. Muscle–eye–brain syndrome (Santavuori et al., 1989; Haltia et al., 1997)

        3. Congenital muscular dystrophy with CBLH (Italian MEB)

                 Genetically defined with frontal predominant COB and AR inheritance

        4. WWS or MEB with POMT1 mutation at 9q34.1 (Beltran-Valero de Bernabe et al., 2002; van Reeuwijk et al., 2006)

        5. WWS or MEB with POMT2 mutation at 14q24.3 (van Reeuwijk et al., 2005; Mercuri et al., 2006)

        6. MEB with POMGnT1 mutation at 1p34–p33 (Manya et al., 2003)

        7. WWS, FCMD or FCMD with retinal abnormality (MEB-like) with FKTN mutation at 9q31 (Beltran-Valero de Bernabe et al., 2003, Manzini et al., 2008, Yoshioka, 2009, Yis et al., 2011)

        8. WWS or MEB with FKRP mutation at 19q13.3 (Beltran-Valero de Bernabe et al., 2004)

        9. WWS or MEB with LARGE mutation at 22q12.3-q13.1 (van Reeuwijk et al., 2007)

                 Genetically defined with posterior predominate COB and AR inheritance

        10. Posterior predominant COB and CMD with LAMA1A mutation at 18p11.31

        11. Posterior predominant COB with LAMC3 mutation at 9q33–q34 (lacks CMD) (Barak et al., 2011)

      2. Cobblestone malformations in CDG

               Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        1. CHIME-like syndrome with frontal predominant COB with SRD5A3 mutation at 4q12 (Al-Gazali et al., 2008; Cantagrel et al., 2010)

        2. Debré-type cutis laxa with frontal predominant COB and ATP6V0A2 mutation at 12q24.3 (Kornak et al., 2008; Van Maldergem et al., 2008)

      3. Cobblestone malformation with no known glycosylation defect

        1. Frontal predominant COB with GPR56 mutations at 16q13 (‘bilateral frontoparietal polymicrogyria’) (Piao et al., 2002, 2005)

        2. Walker-Warburg syndrome secondary to COL4A1 mutations at 13q34 (Labelle-Dumais et al., 2011)

      4. Other syndromes with cortical dysgenesis and marginal glioneuronal heterotopia, but with normal cell types

               Clinically defined with extrinsic or unknown cause

        1. Foetal alcohol syndrome

                 Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        2. Galloway–Mowat syndrome

  3. III. MALFORMATIONS DUE TO ABNORMAL POSTMIGRATIONAL DEVELOPMENT

    • A. MALFORMATIONS WITH PMG OR CORTICAL MALFORMATIONS RESEMBLING PMG

      1. PMG (classic) with transmantle clefts (schizencephaly) or calcification

               Clinically defined with clefts suggesting vascular pathogenesis or unknown cause

        1. Schizencephaly (Barkovich and Kjos, 1992)

        2. Septo-optic dysplasia with schizencephaly (Barkovich et al., 1989)

                 Clinically defined with prenatal viral exposure (especially CMV)

        3. Schizencephaly with positive neonatal CMV testing (Iannetti et al., 1998)

        4. Diffuse or patchy PMG with periventricular calcifications and positive neonatal CMV testing

        5. Diffuse, patchy or perisylvian PMG with hearing loss and positive neonatal CMV testing

                 Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        6. Familial schizencephaly with single unilateral or bilateral clefts (Haverkamp et al., 1995)

        7. Familial schizencephaly with multiple bilateral clefts

        8. Band-like calcifications with PMG (pseudo-TORCH) (Briggs et al., 2008)

                 Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        9. Band-like calcifications with PMG (pseudo-TORCH) with mutations of OCLN1 at 5q13.2 (O'Driscoll et al., 2010)

      2. Polymicrogyria without clefts or calcifications classified by location

               Clinically defined bilateral PMG without clefts of unknown cause

        1. Generalized PMG (Chang et al., 2004)

        2. Frontal PMG (Guerrini et al., 2000)

        3. Perisylvian PMG (Kuzniecky et al., 1993)

        4. Posterior PMG (lateral parieto-occipital) (Barkovich et al., 1999)

        5. Parasagittal PMG

        6. Parasagittal mesial occipital PMG (Guerrini et al., 1997)

                 Clinically defined unilateral PMG without clefts of unknown cause

        7. Hemispheric PMG (Chang et al., 2006)

        8. Perisylvian PMG (Chang et al., 2006)

        9. Focal PMG (Barkovich, 2010a)

      3. Syndromes with PMG (neuropathology may differ from classic PMG)

               Clinically defined syndromes with AD inheritance

        1. Adams–Oliver syndrome AD form (Snape et al., 2009)

                 Clinically defined syndromes with AR inheritance

        2. Adams–Oliver syndrome AR form (Snape et al., 2009)

        3. Joubert syndrome and related disorders with PMG, includes Meckel–Gruber, Arima (cerebro-oculo-renal) and Joubert syndromes with causative genes unknown (Gleeson et al., 2004)

                 Clinically defined syndromes with XL inheritance (probable)

        4. Aicardi syndrome (Aicardi, 2005)

        5. Oculocerebrocutaneous (Delleman) syndrome (Moog et al., 2005)

                 Genetically defined with AD inheritance (new mutations)

        6. Fronto-parietal PMG, variable ACC and delayed myelination of anterior limb internal capsule with TUBB2B mutations at 6p25.2 (Jaglin et al., 2009)

        7. Fronto-parietal PMG, variable with TUBB3 mutations at 16q24.3 (Poirier et al., 2010)

        8. Knobloch syndrome with high myopia, vitreoretinal degeneration, retinal detachment, occipital cephalocele and variable PMG with COL18A1 mutations at 21q22.3 (Sertié et al., 2000)

        9. Aniridia, variable temporal PMG, absent anterior commissure and pineal gland, and variable CBLH with PAX6 mutations at 11p13 (Mitchell et al., 2003; Graziano et al., 2007)

        10. Perisylvian PMG with deletion 1p36.3 (gene not identified) (Dobyns et al., 2008)

        11. Perisylvian PMG with deletion 22q11.2 (gene not identified) (Cramer et al., 1996)

                 Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        12. Goldberg–Shprintzen (megacolon) syndrome with mutations of KIAA1279 at 10q22.1 (Brooks et al., 2005)

        13. Joubert syndrome with variable (low penetrance) PMG and AHI1 mutations at 6q23.3 (Dixon-Salazar et al., 2004; Valente et al., 2006)

        14. Meckel–Gruber syndrome with variable (low penetrance) PMG and TMEM216 mutations at 11q12.2 (Valente et al., 2010)

        15. Generalized (versus perisylvian) PMG, ACC and optic nerve hypoplasia with TUBA8 mutations at 22q11.21 (Abdollahi et al., 2009)

        16. Perisylvian PMG, ACC, delayed myelination of anterior limb internal capsule and cerebellar vermian hypoplasia with mutation of TBR2 (EOMES) at 3p24.1 (Baala et al., 2007)

        17. Warburg Micro syndrome with mutations of RAB3GAP1 at 2q21.3 (Morris-Rosendahl et al., 2010)

        18. Warburg Micro syndrome with mutations of RAB3GAP2 at 1q41 (Borck et al., 2011)

        19. Warburg Micro syndrome with mutations of RAB18 at 10p12.1 (Bem et al., 2011)

                 Genetically defined with XL inheritance

        20. Perisylvian PMG, rolandic seizures and speech-language dyspraxia with SRPX2 at Xq22.1 mutations (Roll et al., 2006, 2010)

        21. Perisylvian PMG, mild MIC and thin body habitus with NSDHL mutation at Xq28 (McLarren et al., 2010)

        22. Perisylvian PMG with Xq27 locus (gene not identified) (Santos et al., 2008)

        23. Perisylvian PMG with Xq28 locus (gene not identified) (Villard et al., 2002)

    • B. CORTICAL DYSGENESIS SECONDARY TO INBORN ERRORS OF METABOLISM (neuropathology differs from classic PMG)

           Genetically and biochemically defined with AR inheritance

      1. Mitochondrial and pyruvate metabolic disorders

        1. Non-ketotic hyperglycinaemia with mutations of GLDC at 9p24.1, GCSH at 16q23.2 or AMT at 3p21.31

        2. Multiple Acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (Glutaric aciduria type II) with mutations of ETFA at 15q24.2-q24.3, ETFB at 19q13.41 or ETFDH at 4q32.1 (Govaert et al., 2004)

      2. Peroxisomal disorders

        1. Zellweger syndrome with mutation of many genes involved in peroxisomal biogenesis (Volpe and Adams, 1972; Steinberg et al., 2006)

        2. Neonatal adrenoleukodystrophy with mutation of many genes involved in peroxisomal biogenesis (Kamei et al., 1993)

        3. D-Bifunctional protein deficiency with HSD17B4 mutation at 5q2 (Grønborg et al., 2010)

    • C. FOCAL CORTICAL DYSPLASIAS (WITHOUT DYSMORPHIC NEURONS) DUE TO LATE DEVELOPMENTAL DISTURBANCES

           Clinically/histologically defined and sporadic

      1. Minor malformations of Cortical Development (mMCD)

      2. Type I FCD

        1. Abnormal radial cortical lamination (Blümcke et al., 2011)

        2. Abnormal tangential cortical lamination (Blümcke et al., 2011)

        3. Abnormal radial and tangential lamination (Blümcke et al., 2011)

      3. Type III FCD

        1. Associated with hippocampal sclerosis (Blümcke et al., 2011)

        2. Associated with tumors (Blümcke et al., 2011)

        3. Associated with vascular malformations (Blümcke et al., 2011)

        4. Associated with other principal lesions during early life (Blümcke et al., 2011)

    • D. POSTMIGRATIONAL DEVELOPMENTAL MICROCEPHALY (PREVIOUSLY POSTNATAL MIC) WITH BIRTH OFC –3 SD OR LARGER, LATER OFC BELOW –4 SD AND NO EVIDENCE OF BRAIN INJURY

      1. Postmigrational MIC with limited functional deficits

               Clinically defined

        1. Postmigrational MIC with no cause or syndrome identified

                 Genetically defined with AD inheritance (sporadic new mutations)

        2. MIC and mild ID with SHH mutation (Ginocchio et al., 2008)

        3. MIC and variable ACC with deletion 1q43q44 (includes AKT3) (Hill et al., 2007)

      2. Postmigrational MIC with broad functional deficits consistent with a ‘developmental encephalopathy’ (Angelman-like, Rett-like class of disorders)

               Clinically defined with AR inheritance

        1. PEHO syndrome (Salonen et al., 1991; Vanhatalo et al., 2002)

                 Genetically defined with AD inheritance (sporadic new mutations)

        2. Pitt–Hopkins syndrome with mutations of TCF4 at 18q21.1 (Zweier et al., 2007)

        3. FOXG1 syndrome with deletions or mutations of FOXG1 at 14q13 (Kortüm et al., 2011)

        4. Duplication of FOXG1 at 14q13 (Brunetti-Pierri et al., 2011)

                 Genetically defined with AD inheritance (or pathogenic de novo copy number variant) and imprinting effects

        5. Maternal duplication 15q11.2 (Kitsiou-Tzeli et al., 2010)

        6. Angelman syndrome with maternally deletion 15q11.2 or mutation of UBE3A at 15q11.2 (Matsuura et al., 1997)

                 Genetically defined with AR inheritance

        7. Pitt–Hopkins like syndrome with mutations of NRXN1 at 2p16.3 (Zweier et al., 2009)

        8. Pitt–Hopkins-like syndrome with mutations of CNTNAP2 at 7q35-q36 (Zweier et al., 2009)

        9. Pontocerebellar hypoplasia with mutations of TSEN54 at 17q25.1, TSEN2 at 3p25.1, TSEN34 at 19q13.4, RARS2 at 6q16.1 (Namavar et al., 2011)

                 Genetically defined with XL inheritance

        10. Rett syndrome with mutations of MECP2 at Xq28 (Amir et al., 1999)

        11. Angelman-like syndrome with mutations of SLC9A6 at Xq26.3 (Gilfillan et al., 2008)

        12. X-linked mental retardation and autistic features with mutations of JARID1C at xp11.22–p11.21 (Jensen et al., 2005; Abidi et al., 2008)

        13. X-linked MIC with disproportionate cerebellar hypoplasia with mutations of CASK at Xp11.4 (in females) (Najm et al., 2008)

  • ACC = agenesis of corpus callosum; AD = autosomal dominant inheritance; AR = autosomal recessive inheritance; CBLH = cerebellar hypoplasia; CDG = congenital disorders of glycosylation; CHIME = coloboma, heart defect, ichthyosiform dermatosis, mental retardation, ear anomalies; CMD = congential muscular dystrophy; CMV = cytomegalovirus; COB = cobblestone complex; DD/ID = developmental delay/intellectual disability; DNET = dysembryoplastic neuroepithelial tumour; FCMD = Fukuyama congenital muscular dystrophy; HMEG = hemimegalencephaly; ILS = isolated lissencephaly syndrome; IUGR = intrauterine growth retardation; LCH = lissencephaly with cerebellar hypoplasia; LIS = lissencephaly; MACS = macrocephaly, alopecia, cutis laxa, scoliosis; MAP = microcephaly with asymmetric polymicrogyria; MCPH = autosomal recessive primary microcephaly; MDP = microcephaly with diffuse polymicrogyria; MEB = muscle–eye–brain syndrome; MEG = megalencephaly; MIC = microcephaly; MLIS = microcephaly with lissencephaly; MOPD = microcephalic osteodysplastic primordial dwarfism syndrome; MPPH = megalencephaly with polymicrogyria, polydactyly and hydrocephalus; PEHO = progressive encephalopathy with oedema, hypsarrhythmia and optic atrophy; PLH = periventricular laminar heterotopia; PMG = polymicrogyria; PMSE = polyhydramnios, megalencephaly and symptomatic epilepsy; PNH = periventricular nodular heterotopia; SBH = subcortical band heterotopia; SIMP = simplified gyral pattern; WWS = Walker–Warburg syndrome; XL = X-linked inheritance; XLAG = X-linked lissencephaly with agenesis of corpus callosum and ambiguous genitalia.

  • Appendix 1

    Full classification scheme

    Abbreviations
    FCD
    focal cortical dysplasia

    This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0), which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

    References

    View Abstract